Board of Trustee member Scott Holman flies a private plane and stays in a suite at the Landmark when he comes to town for NMU Board of Trustee meetings, according to travel receipts obtained by The North Wind through a Freedom of Information Act request.
Holman, head of the board’s finance committee and a former chair, uses a plane through his private company, Bay Cast Aviation Services LLC, and is reimbursed for the price of a commercial flight; the rest of the bill he donates to NMU.
Holman donated $1,800, his entire plane cost, in late March 2014, which took him from the Cayman Islands to Detroit and back to the Caribbean. The donations do not go through the NMU Foundation, wrote NMU spokesman Derek Hall in an email.
When other trustees are on board, however, Holman is reimbursed in full for the private plane, which includes the pilot’s lodging and food. On April 16, Holman flew Trustees Steve Mitchell, Rick Popp, H. Sook Wilkinson and Thomas Zurbuchen to Willow Run airport in Ypsilanti, Mich. from Marquette to avoid an incoming snowstorm, according to the receipts. He was reimbursed $1,200 for that trip.
Five days later, Holman flew Mitchell, Popp and Wilkinson both ways and was reimbursed $2,300.
Holman has been reimbursed for his flights four times, twice at $737, for a total of $5,038.
The majority of the other trustees fly coach out of Detroit Metro Airport or drive up from downstate. Plane tickets range from $800 to $1,200.
Trustee H. Sook Wilkinson, a clinical psychologist and author, spent $11,000 in travel in the last year. She submitted travel expenses for reimbursement every board meeting, while other trustees didn’t.
“As a Michigan resident since 1975, I feel strongly about giving back to the state of Michigan and the United States,” Wilkinson wrote in an email. “Prior to applying for the NMU board, I served on the board of many non-profits including an educational institution.”
Between Jan. 1, 2014 and Feb. 10, 2015, the trustees spent $30,000 on transportation. More than half of that, $17,500, was spent during the presidential search last year. The trustees spent $20,300 on hotels over the last year, $3,200 by Holman alone. According to Hall, the university has a deal with the Landmark Inn in which it pays about $100 a night for a standard room.
The majority of the trustees stay in these rooms. However, Holman stays in a suite, according to the receipts, costing about $200 a night. Overall, Holman spent $1,600 more than if he had stayed in a standard room.
Also included in Holman’s hotel total is an extra room taken out in Holman’s name for $103, on April 16, which was “used for informal board discussions,” according to a handwritten note by Holman on the receipt. “Less than a quorum” was present, the note said.
“The trustees use a suite at the Landmark Inn as a quiet place to gather for team building and to meet with donors, alums and community members,” Chair of the Board Rick Popp wrote in an email. “It would be inappropriate to meet in someone’s regular hotel room and the suite is often a better location than a bar or a restaurant.
Trustee Holman’s suite is available to all trustees during our visits to Marquette as we fulfill our duties as volunteer board members.”
Popp stayed in a suite July 16-20, 2014, costing just under $900.
Board meetings that week took place July 17 and 18; however, according to Popp, the university paid for his hotel room the rest of the weekend so he could attend an alumni event.
The university covers travel expenses for the board, which includes transportation to and from the meeting, hotels and meals. Also included are “miscellaneous” expenses, which according to the Board of Trustees secretary, include meals during the meetings, A/V equipment and lodging for the legal counsel.
In the last year miscellaneous expenses totaled more than $33,821— about 45 percent of the total board expenditure last year.
In the last year the trustees spent $2,400 at The Northland Pub and Capers Restaurant, both located in the Landmark Inn. On one evening, Dec. 10, Steve Mitchell spent $155 at Capers.
The rest of the meals appear in single receipts from restaurants like The Vierling or in the miscellaneous column in the expense reports.
It is unclear how much was spent on food during meetings because, apart from the May 2 Board of Trustees meeting, there is no specific denotation on food. During the May 2 meeting, trustees were charged $6,600 for “conference and catering,” according to the expense records. The average miscellaneous cost of board meetings is $3,500.
The Board of Trustees is made up of eight governor-appointed members who serve eight year terms; the president of the university acts as an ex-officio member. According to the bylaws, the board “has general supervision of the institution and the control and direction of all expenditures from the institution’s funds.”
Marc Turner • Apr 17, 2015 at 10:14 am
Maybe it’s time to have NMU administrators and trustees review the United States Constitution (along with Michigan Constitution and law) regarding freedom of the press to report to the constituent public and students on the accurate expenses and costs submitted by state university trustees?
The trustees/administration have the power and means to disagree with the very good reporting but are obviously embarrassed by their behavior as they help themselves to the trough of education dollars meant for Michigan students.
Because of the trustee/administration action, more state education dollars must be spent defending and ultimately settling with the newspaper in federal court for their illegal actions in suppressing the student newspaper’s freedom of the press.
Maybe the trustees could find a local school booster group to embezzle funds.
Reeader • Mar 31, 2015 at 4:51 pm
It would be helpful to compare these expenses to LSSU and MTU, the other two state universities in the Upper Peninsula. I suspect the universities in the Lower Peninsula have reduced board expenses because there is lesser travel distance involved. I really don’t understand why the trustees aren’t afforded meeting space or offices on campus to reduce the need for what appears to be smoke-filled backroom meetings that most likely are just one member short of a quorum and are seldom, if ever, noticed to the public. Also, one could make the case for NMU to invest in an on-campus guest house.
Ivy • Mar 26, 2015 at 1:54 pm
North Wind you did an excellent job on researching and reporting of data. As an employee of Columbia University Medical Center, whom frequently compiles travel and business expenses for Executive level employees here at Columbia, the expenditures seem quite reasonable in most cases and fall within the guidelines of what our university sees as customary and usual. However, the response of the Trustee Chair, Rich Popp, proved that he felt a need to be defensive of what is being spent. Why be so defensive if you are following the policies that are outlined by the university in regards to spending? Why speak so negatively of the writing and editorial staff of the university paper of which your Board is supposed to be representing and supporting? This exposes what one might perceive as behavior indicating that something untoward is happening in the shadows. The reporting in the article was very straightforward. Not at all sensationalized from an outsider’s perspective. It wasn’t until I saw the email distributed by Mr. Popp that I felt that something may be amiss. The attitude that the reporter was in any way mediocre or lax in representing the data, appears to be a desperate attempt to dissuade further investigation into the Board’s activities.
Kevin • Mar 25, 2015 at 5:58 pm
First class-less journalism North Wind. Try doing a follow up story on everything Scott Holman has done for the University. These “expenditures” are a drop in an ocean of donations and contributions to NMU. Which some of you at North Wind most likely have taken advantage of. Hypocrisy at it’s finest.
Alex • Mar 25, 2015 at 5:43 pm
I am writing this in response to Rick Popp’s email which was sent to every student this morning. His email was an explicit demonstration that he is not only an opponent of transparency, but a shameful sensationalist. His email was clearly intended to mislead students and faculty who had not yet read this North Wind article.
It seems to me, and you may agree, that such behavior has no place in the transparent and supportive academic environment that our new President Fritz is trying to foster. While I have no affiliation with the North Wind, nor am I a consistent reader, I take issue with several statements Rick Popp made. I have carefully read the article and found his statements to be utterly false, and as I said earlier, sensationalist. This story was clearly not an effort to disrespect or discredit any individuals; in fact there is no statement within the entire article that could be construed as doing so. There wasn’t even the slightest insinuation that the hotel suite is located just blocks from NMU’s campus, where a myriad of facilities exist which offer a far more appropriate venue for team building and meetings with donors and alums. Nor was there mention that excellent dining opportunities exist on campus which would also be more appropriate for trustees to patronize during their stay. Anyone that’s ever had a meal at Capers can tell you that $155 wouldn’t cover the meals of 8 students either. Instead, there were only facts listed in this article, which were in no way disrespectful.
Popp’s suggestion that this was the case made his inability to critically analyze writing quite clear. If such an analysis were turned in to the professors of our English department for credit, it would not earn a passing grade. Such ineptitude is evidence that he is unfit to serve the university with his attitude and current skill set. With further proper instruction and coursework at our fine institution, this might be corrected, but until he is able to understand and demonstrate the basics of analysis, it is clear he cannot serve our university as well as another more qualified individual. Nor should there be any position at our university that should be held by an individual with such attitudes.
Thus far I have been impressed with President Erickson’s support of transparency at our university. It seemed as though the former administration’s well-known tolerance and fostering of such threatening and unprofessional behavior had finally come to an end. I am writing this now because i hope this is still the case, as I trust it is.
Rick Popp’s email should never have been allowed to be sent campus-wide in its current form. I hope that the president will take action so that such accusatory, false statements will not be spread to students in such a manner again, no matter what position the author holds. I think any reasonable individual would agree that the only appropriate place for such writing would have been within the North Wind itself in a letter to the editor, or in the comments section here. For such a gross offense and abuse of position, I am supporting a call for Rick Popp’s resignation of his position as the chair of the NMU board of trustees. I understand that some administrators may consider Rick Popp a close personal friend, but it is my hope they will not let that get in the way of taking the appropriate measures to respond to, censure, and prevent such behavior by any university employee in the future. I look forward to hearing President Erickson’s response on this issue and an assurance that this will not happen again under his leadership.
Anon • Mar 25, 2015 at 3:05 pm
North Wind was utterly destroyed by Rick Popp, chair of NMU Board of Trustees in a recent student-body wide email. Poor and mediocre research done on the student journalist’s part, and now their credibility is paying the price.
“Sensational in it’s headlines, not so sensational in its research”.
Thank you Rick, for putting these journalists in their place.
Max • Mar 21, 2015 at 10:52 am
The Northwind has really been doing a terrific job in exposing what really goes in with the NMU administration. They take very good care of themselves over in Cohodas with little regard for the rest of the NMU community. Keep up the great reporting.