Since the medical marijuana law was legalized in a proposition approved by Michigan voters in 2008, people have been scratching their heads. The law is overly confusing, leaving many aspects of the new medical marijuana industry in a grey area.
Its intentions were noble. The law allows for a person with a chronic illness to apply for a medical marijuana card in order to obtain marijuana and use it to ease their pain. In some cases, patients feel marijuana is the most effective medicine for their condition. A person with a medical marijuana card is allowed to grow up to 12 plants for their own use and possess 2.5 ounces, or enlist a caregiver to grow it for them. The caregiver is allowed to provide for five patients, growing up to 12 plants for each of them.
From there, things become confused. In March, a district judge in the Detroit suburb of Dearborn named Mark Somers ruled in a case that Michigan’s medical marijuana law is both illegal and trumped by federal laws, according to an article in the Associated Press. Though his decision is by no means binding outside of Dearborn, the decision sheds light on a growing dissatisfaction with the law.

But just in case anyone was worried that Somers was wrong and that federal law didn’t trump state law, on April 12, Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) agents raided a medical marijuana facility in Walled Lake, Mich. Caregivers of America is a marijuana dispensary, a facility patients can go to find caregivers to grow pot for them. It’s also a head shop.
Though the dispensary was a part of a major four-location bust of one of the people associated with Caregivers of America, the raid clearly shows us once again that federal law supersedes state law.
By many accounts, the Caregivers of America were perfectly law-abiding under Michigan law. So even when people are perfectly law-abiding Michigan citizens, there’s still federal law to worry about.
If you have a medical marijuana card, you could go to a dispensary for your medicine needs – but right now, the legality of dispensaries under state law are still being debated. Even if it’s decided they are legal, they aren’t under federal law, so there’s always the chance their caregiver (or dealer, depending on which lens we’re viewing this through) could get busted while trying to grow their much-needed medicine. They could grow it themselves, but you’d probably have trouble.
There’s one loophole which does benefit the medical marijuana cardholder –– in their great wisdom, someone forgot to put something in there about taxation. As such, everyone’s pretty sure you don’t have to pay tax on medical marijuana.
People who have the medical card are supposed to have serious medical conditions and many might not be experienced with buying marijuana illegally or growing it. If they wanted to turn to the Michigan Medical Marihuana Program (MMMP), the organization which registers patients with cards, for help with growing marijuana, buying seeds or finding a caregiver, the MMMP would refuse them.
According to the MMMP FAQ page, “The MMMP is not a resource for the growing process and does not have information to give to patients.” As such, the MMMP forces patients to go to the Internet, to dealers or to pseudo-legal dispensaries for their marijuana growing or buying needs.
Imagine you get perscribed Adderrall or Prozac and then are told that your doctor cannot tell you where to get it or where to go to find the answers to your questions. This would not only be irresponsible, it would border on outright denying treatment.
In fact, the MMMP and the law is so out of touch with the reality of the situation, they don’t even spell marijuana with a “j.” Instead, they spell it with an “h.” In the MMMP’s FAQ page, the reason for the “h” is this: “Marihuana is one of two acceptable spellings in the dictionary.” It goes on to say the spelling is consistent with previous wording in Michigan laws.
Let’s get real here for a moment. The state believes that “marihuana” is a very powerful and much-needed medicine for some patients. Meanwhile, everyone is pretending that marijuana is a terrible thing for someone to do unless they have a serious condition. Everyone acts as though they have not smoked the product themselves. Many of us – I’d venture to say most – have tried pot at least once.
This law needs clarification. People who need this as medicine need to know how to procure it. They need to know what protection they have under the law. It’s outrageous that the loopholes and greyness of this law have been allowed to continue.
buy cannabis seeds • Jan 27, 2014 at 12:41 am
Hi there folks everbody is aware of marijuana has become legalized pertaining to exciting features during Uruguay plus in a couple of claims inside of U . s ., whatrrrs your opinion about it? you think that which in turn legalisation regarding pot is often a valuable a single or simply poor?
Das • Apr 18, 2011 at 12:07 am
Logically people should get the medicines they need, and logically doctors should be responsible for prescribing narcotics. But alas, California has similar laws and Californians have made a mockery of them. Californians can get a prescription card by meeting with a doctor right there in the “pharmacy”. To them it’s all one big joke. But sadly, this is what the world will see when considering revamping federal laws – and it’s bound to ruin it for folks who really do need this drug.
andy • Apr 15, 2011 at 2:27 am
I don’t know who the sources are in this article, but to say:
“There’s one loophole which does benefit the medical marijuana cardholder –– in their great wisdom, someone forgot to put something in there about taxation. As such, everyone’s pretty sure you don’t have to pay tax on medical marijuana.
Is merely uninformed jargon. Anybody who tells you don’t have to pay tax on ANYTHING is somebody you should at least stop listening to. You people are talking about whether or not uncle sam is ok with you growing marijuana. HELLO! If you pay taxes he is infinitly more likely to look the other way.
There is no loophole. I’d like to hear a lawyer tell me that. The law clearly states that no money is passed for medication, it is the time/labor/materials, costs associated with procuring the medicine; that is what has a monetary value. And that is what you pay taxes on. If you get paid for anything you better believe they will get their cut. Whether you like it or not
James • Apr 15, 2011 at 12:38 am
The law is fine. What needs an overhaul is the whole reefer madness bad identity thing. Federal law sucks.
ac24221 • Apr 14, 2011 at 5:23 pm
Who do we trust to make these changes, someone like Judge Sutton who refers to cannabis in open court as Satan’s weed or the Attorney General who is openly against cannabis use. Do not forget it was not the Bozo’s who run this state who got us this far. It was the people of the state of Michigan. All those and I do mean all; that complain about the law are in one way or another looking for loopholes in the law to stop medical cannabis. The law does not give them the authority to control what was previously illegal so they complain it needs to be fixed. Every time someone has a couple of drinks in a bar and then climbs into their car they are breaking laws. No one needs to clarify or rewrite these laws; they just exist and are for the most part ignored by the same people who are calling for a reworked compassion law in order to jail us. We will win but in the mean time many sick and hurting people are going to jail and the bars keep serving away.
William • Apr 14, 2011 at 4:43 pm
I’m against marijuana legalization. However, I’m not sure the answer to the problem is to throw people in jail for having a small amount of marijuana. This creates crowding in the jails and prisons. Maybe instead, the authorities should give harsh, draconian fines to people who possess small amounts of marijuana (Like perhaps fine them hundreds maybe even thousands of dollars). Then use the money for student aid, grants, and scholarships??? Of course, if someone has large amounts of marijuana, is dealing it to people, trafficking it, or is selling it to minors, then I think they should definitely go to prison. But for possessing a small amount of marijuana I think a HARSH fine might be a good idea.
BZ • Apr 14, 2011 at 3:28 pm
The medical marijuana law doesn’t need to be revamped or overhauled, federal marijuana laws are what needs to be overhauled! Classifying marijuana as a Schedule I drug should be a crime in itself. It won’t be long, the People of America aren’t going to stand for this much longer. Even if you don’t use marijuana, you know someone who does… and nobody thinks its right that they (or a friend or family member) can be arrested and prosecuted for possessing any amount of marijuana while everyone else is free to buy and drink as much alcohol as they want. It’s time for balance to be restored in everyone’s freedom… prohibition has FAILED.
ConservativChristian • Apr 14, 2011 at 9:58 am
Jesus said to do unto others as we would have them to do unto us. None of us would want our child thrown in jail with the sexual predators for using a little marijuana. None of us would want to see our parent’s home confiscated and sold by the police for growing a couple of marijuana plants to ease the aches and pains of growing older. It’s time to stop putting our own families in jail. It’s time to let ordinary Americans grow a little marijuana in their own back yards, and it’s nice to see our culture coming to terms with this in a more wholesome fashion. This will go a long way toward putting the criminal drug gangs out of business for good! Also, check out http://www.northpoint.org/ if you’d like to see some more very positive material about Jesus at work in people’s lives.