A few weeks ago, I wrote about how America needs to remove religion from government and politics. I described atheists as a minority group, and lumped myself in with them. As any article about religion is apt to do, I offended a few readers. No sweat, right? But there was one critic that I could never forgive myself for insulting. I’m sorry Grandma.
Now let me stop you right there. Cast those images of a brittle old lady out of your mind right now. At 82, my Southern Baptist-raised granny is as tenacious as she was at 22. If you met her, you’d be apologizing, too. If you ever crossed her, you’d be running. But I don’t write this out of fear. Few are more compassionate and caring than my dear old grammy.
While Grandma Dyer is a devout Christian, she would be the first person to tell you that there are more than a few groups out there giving God a bad name. But the vast majority of Christians don’t make it to prime time on Fox News, where they are allowed to spit hateful rhetoric. Just like my grammy, there are kind, spiritual and accepting Christians everywhere. They are the true silent majority.
Religion, more specifically Christianity, is a tool as well as a belief. As such, it can be used and abused accordingly. For some, God is a way to come to terms with themselves and find understanding in life. For others, it’s an excuse to exclude anyone who is different. The morality of Christianity is determined less by overall doctrine than it is by the individual practicing it. Jerks will be jerks, no matter which God they worship.
As a teenager first starting high school, religion was always a concept I struggled with. I always wanted to believe, but when I was forced to defend the same core religion shared by the Westboro Baptist Church, creationists and abortion clinic bombers, I lost faith.
But, with a little help from my grammy, I came to realize that religion has an immense benefit to secular society as well. So often do we get caught up in the semantics of the existence or nonexistence of God that we forget about the core message of Christianity –– the message to live, to love and, most important of all, to forgive.
Regardless if you believe in a Judeo-Christian God or not, it’s hard to argue with the positive results that religion is capable of achieving. Whether it’s using a higher power to defeat alcoholism in Alcoholics Anonymous meetings or a convicted felon finding redemption through the teachings of the Bible, religion has the capability to help even the most downtrodden soul find meaning in life.
But in that same breath, religion (even specifically Christianity) is capable of tremendous evil. Looking back to the millions upon millions slaughtered during numerous Crusades, the wars of the Prostestant reformation, the inquisition of Spain and the Salem witch trials, it’s enough to wonder if religion is worth it at all.
When you look past contradicting rhetoric and actually look at the guidelines that Christians are supposed to abide by, it’s difficult to see how any of these atrocities are reinforced. In reading literal teachings of Jesus as recorded in the new testament (you know, what Christians are supposed to follow in the first place) it’s hard to come away with anything other than a message of love. Love for your neighbor, love for the poor, the downtrodden, love for the meek and even love for your enemy … it’s enough love to make a hippie on Valentine’s Day sick to his stomach.
The real enemy in the war of faith is not believers, nor is it non-believers. It is the ignorant. Those who see their religion as a trophy, to be flaunted in the face of their opponents. Those who go on TV and compare homosexuals to wild animals and promote intolerance towards other forms of belief. It is these people who should be the outcasts of our society.
I never really got my faith in God back in a literal sense, but I still attend church as often as I can. Why? Even though I’m an atheist, the majority of churches that I’ve attended immediately accepted me as family. Maybe it’s selfish, but going to church makes me feel good. And frankly, that’s all that really matters to me.
That, and I go for the delicious after-church snacks. Because if God is anywhere, he’s in the church snacks.
Rev Chris Ward • Dec 4, 2011 at 9:35 am
Beware the false prophets… ye shall know them by their fruits. Do men gather grapes or thorns, figs or thistles…” Matthew 7:15-17
11-11-11 sent 11:11 pm EST:
GET THIS… After making their family fortunes on the backs of the American Working Class, American ideas/ingenuity and infrastructure paid for by the American TAXPAYER… these spoiled, Ivy League Aristocrats had the audacity to buy off our politicians and news media so they could ravage and expatriate most of our nation’s wealth and resources.
The greatest looting in the history of mankind happened during the Bush/Cheney disaster. A corporate crime wave of epic proportions and the Conservative wackos are stuck on stupid STILL blaming the Left.
WHY or HOW has this happened? Well it’s all about false prophets, lots and LOT’S of false prophets. Go to any Evangelical Christian Fundamentalist church in the USA and really LISTEN to the message.
Sermons from coast to coast seem to have basic underlying theme any right-wing primate could understand. (lol) “Liberal bad, Conservative good”. Ohhhh, and JESUS is a money changing, right-wing, war hawk who preached against abortion.
It might be the Conservative think tanks… It might be FOX News or AM Radio Free Conservative… What about all the foreigners like Rupert Murdock, Communist Chinese and Saudi Royals buying up American assets?
It may be the mailing lists. I’ll bet there isn’t a right-wing Christian in the WEST who hasn’t received a mailer hyping the famous Conservative transsexual Ann Coulter and her book “Godless Liberals”.
LISTEN to the mental sickness and low grade thought processes coming from the mouths of Republicans. See the right-wing Evangelical Christian Fundamentalists get played like pitiful fools. Like GOD would have anything to do with all the greed, racism, hate speech and environmental degradation. These people are so deluded they actually believe JESUS (Prince of Peace) and war profiteers are on the same side. That JESUS (the healer) would be against affordable healthcare for all. COME ON!
Christians need to learn a con is a CON! No matter in a back alley or from the Ivory Towers the trick is to RECOGNIZE IT… and not get played for a FOOL.
I’ve been saying for years a few fanatical terrorists who perverted Islam don’t scare me near as much as those FOOLS who believe Capitalism can survive without ETHICS, RESPOSNIBILITY and ACCOUNTABILITY! The FIGHT is here at home… everyone in the USA needs to come together and get involved BEFORE the silver spoon, trust fund baby aristocrats throw you in debtor’s prison. These bastards would bring back slavery if they could but inmates working for 23 cents a day is the next best thing. Republicans turned us all into the United Suckers of America.
Like I always tell my Conservative friends, this ain’t no Tea Party, this is a bleeping Class War”. I’ll tell you why the Republicans hate the US government so much. Our government is the only thing strong enough to hold this neo-con criminal enterprise accountable, but only if the people force the government to do IT’S JOB.” See jinnbad.blogspot.com for more.
QUOTE OF THE DAY:
“…In Princess Ann Coulter’s Ivory Tower world, Reaganomics or Trickle-down economics hasn’t failed on a massive scale for the American PEOPLE. Let’s all conveniently forget Bush/Cheney almost destroyed Middle Class America… the important thing is that the billionaires are doing great, right?
Maybe those 16 multi-national corporations (the Supreme Court and Chamber of Commerce bends over for on a daily basis) should start reinvesting in the USA. Ayn Rand or Machiavelli can’t explain away what these silver spoon, trust fund babies did to the American PEOPLE… If the Warriors had any balls they’d whack the Koch Bros, Rupert Murdoch and Karl Rove” CHARLIE STUNATS
Helen Beelen • Dec 2, 2011 at 9:54 pm
I have to say–I was surprised at this article. The article from several weeks ago was at least more dogged (if a little historically inaccurate)… this seems almost defensive.
That aside, I fundamentally disagree with this analysis of the “pros” of religion, and to a lesser extent, the “cons.”.
Firstly, life, love, and forgiveness are presented here as the machinations of Christianity; religion is, apparently, the moral arbiter of our lives. This doesn’t even make sense. Faith does not equal morals.
Secondly, that “silent majority”? I’d bet the meager amount in my bank account that these Christians don’t actually read the Bible, and if they do, they skip lightly over the Old Testament and jump right into the gospels and Paul’s letters. Let’s be honest. The God of the Old Testament (and remember, He is constant–but somehow still mercurial) is a jerk. Read the Pentateuch. Sure, Jesus is a nice guy–I’d love to have a beer with the guy–but his heavenly father would need a few promotions just to be an asshole.
As for the “cons” of religion… Of course the issues raised are important; the Crusades, the Spanish Inquisition, and the witch trials were horrific eras… but what about today? What about when the Pope goes to Africa and says that condoms spread AIDS? Or when the institution condemns homosexuality? Religiously-founded bullying and hatred results not just in the more publicized suicides but in heavy guilt and confusion. And this isn’t restricted to sexuality.
It is not at all difficult to see how these atrocities are reinforced: Leviticus 18, 20, & 22 (or really the entire book).
My personal views of Christianity as pure fiction aside, I don’t have a problem with personal piety. I don’t have a problem with comforting fellowship the church offers. If it brings you some sort of equanimity, go for it.
I have a problem when this piety and this fellowship become a public nuisance; when the private beliefs of the mind spill over and the fellowship of the church creeps into the street.
MR • Dec 2, 2011 at 1:11 pm
Every religion has the capacity for peace, even though every religion has segments that detract from that. Most world religions have had horrendous acts attributed to them over the course of history, and they have also contributed to society in some form of positive manner. I don’t think that’s the real issue.
Honestly, a lot of the crazy-devout “loud minority” religious people believe that religion creates morality, and thus if you are not religious you do not live by a moral code. They use their religion to justify why atheists, spiritualists, and even sometimes those who believe in monism are living terribly immoral lives and must thus convert. That is what most frustrates me about the so-called “ignorant” or “loud minority”
Rita • Dec 2, 2011 at 9:22 am
Thank you so very much for sharing this….
I am a devout Christain that tries to practice her faith in similar ways as your grandmother.
I am also a transgender woman. When I told the church I was attending (charismatic evangelical) I was frozen out. Many like me abandon belief in God because of such treatment. But this is not the God I know …. my God is the God of love you have described. I feel a closer and deeper relationship with that God because of my struggles.
Again, thank you so much for sharing this…
Rita
Robert Stovold • Dec 2, 2011 at 7:52 am
“it’s hard to come away with anything other than a message of love”
“Do not think that I came to bring peace on Earth; I did not come to bring peace, but a sword. For I came to set a man against his father, and a daughter against her mother, and a daughter-in-law against her mother-in-law; and a man’s enemies will be the members of his household. He who loves father or mother more than Me is not worthy of Me; and he who loves son or daughter more than Me is not worthy of Me. And he who does not take his cross and follow Me is not worthy of Me. He who has found his life will lose it, and he who has lost his life for My sake will find it.” (Matthew 10:34-39 )
When it comes ot the verses Christians ought to be following, even the New Testament says that gays deserve to be put to death, and that most people are going to hell. Of course there are are nice verses in the New Testament – but since tjhe ideas behind them have been around long before Jesus, why call yourself Christian?
If you’rea fan of “Gentle Jesus”, try reading this….
http://www.atheistfoundation.org.au/articles/christianity-debit-account
Robert Vroom • Dec 2, 2011 at 6:02 am
Overall, a very good article. I disagree with one statement you made in it. You said, “religion (even specifically Christianity) is capable of tremendous evil.” This is poorly worded. It is more fair to say that religious people (specifically Chrisitans)… Saying that Christianity is capable of evil blames the belief for the actions of people who abuse the name of the belief, and it is not fair to judge a belief by those who abuse it.
Larry Linn • Dec 1, 2011 at 7:24 pm
Social commentator and former alter-boy George Carlin sums it up, “Think about it. Religion has actually convinced people that there’s an invisible man living in the sky who watches everything you do, every minute of every day. And the invisible man has a special list of ten things he does not want you to do. And if you do any of these ten things, he has a special place, full of fire and smoke and burning and torture and anguish, where he will send you to live and suffer and burn and choke and scream and cry forever and ever ’til the end of time! But He loves you. He loves you, and He needs money! He always needs money! He’s all-powerful, all-perfect, all-knowing, and all-wise, somehow just can’t handle money! Religion takes in billions of dollars, they pay no taxes, and they always need a little more. Now, you talk about a good bull*** story. Holy S***!”
DKeane • Dec 1, 2011 at 5:53 pm
Whether something induces positive results does not have any bearing on how true it is or isn’t.