As many athletes know, the NCAA has a substantial amount of rules and regulations. Many of these are necessary measures, namely those that have to do with amateurism and drugs. The regulations that seem unnecessary and hinder many student-athletes are those dealing with academics; Division II of the NCAA (the one NMU belongs to) requires that once students reach junior standing, they must be progressing towards a single degree.
Each institution is responsible for interpreting what making progress toward degree means. At Northern, student athletes must have declared a major by the time they reach junior standing. From that third year and beyond, 12 credits must be completed each semester that advance them closer to that single baccalaureate or equivalent degree. They may only have a minor if that degree requires one.
This rule makes it nearly impossible for student athletes like me, who are interested in a double major or minor, to achieve the academic goals they set for themselves in their academic careers. I want to double major in English writing and biology, but I can only advance in one degree beginning next fall. As an athlete and a student, I should have the right to graduate once with two degrees.
Student-athlete members of the NCAA have a limited number of years of eligibility that they can participate in college athletics. The NCAA limits student-athletes to four seasons of competition within 10 semesters of full-time education. There is still the possibility of a redshirt, administered for medical, academic or other reasons, which means that an athlete does not participate in a competitive season and therefore retains the year of eligibility.
Since the limited years of eligibility prohibit a student from veering off the educational track in order to remain in college athletics longer than it would normally take to graduate, there shouldn’t be a requirement for student athletes to take a single academic route.
These requirements might make sense for Division I athletics which tend to be at both a higher athletic and scholarship level. This makes it more likely that student athletes are attending college perhaps as a transition between high school and professional sports and less for the education college provides. Division II, however, focuses on the balance between athletics and academics.
The progress-toward-degree policy is unsuitable for students with not only athletic goals, but also high academic goals. I believe this policy conflicts with one of the NCAA’s core values, “The pursuit of excellence in both academics and athletics,” and should be made more flexible for students who have different paths in mind.

























Paul Kimpling • Feb 21, 2011 at 1:40 am
It’s hard to believe that the NCAA intentionally would contradict itself.
Regardless, this is a serious loop-hole that needs to be addressed.
Currently a fifth-year senior, Environmental Sciences Major and “kinda” Civil Engineering Major. I am currently investigating this very topic, and am writing a formal recommendation for NCAA administrators to amend rules that allow(better yet, Encourage) DII students-athletes pursue a double-major.
The progress-towards-your-degree policy was originally placed to increase graduation rates among student-athletes. It prevented students from taking easier courses during the season- who then would dropout after their eligibility had been exhausted.
Two words: Academically Ineligible
Not for underacheiving, but overacheiveing…
….confused? I was!
Registered for 18 credits, I was deemed academically ineligible because I only had 11 credits towards my “primary” major(instead of the required 12). Taking science courses, then adding engineering classes for my second major(between labs/ intensity of study/volume of work), it is easy to see that I was not looking for a cop out.
In order to compete- or even practice. These rules force you to 1) add another course(typically 3 credits each) ; 2) simply switch a “secondary major” course to a “primary”
course ; OR 3) choose not to compete in athletics.
For me, adding another course would mean 21 credits + collegiate sport which could produce disastrous results. Therefore, the second choice seems obvious. However, you can’t earn a degree taking only one course every semester. Additionally, majors are designed to build and feed off of one another- when one semester worth of classes is spread over 1-1/2 years, you not only fall behind, but classes become significantly more challenging.
Been there and done that • Nov 11, 2010 at 9:25 am
This seems a little misinformed. This student-athlete needs to talk to an adviser or the compliance officer. There have been student-athletes at NMU and other institutions who graduated with a double major. I am one.