The Student News Site of Northern Michigan University

The North Wind

The North Wind

The North Wind

Meet the Staff
Lily Gouin
Lily Gouin
Assistant Sports Editor

Hi! My name is Lily Gouin I am in my third year here at NMU. I am from Appleton, WI majoring in communications and double minoring in multimedia journalism and public relations. In my free time, I like...

The North Wind Editorial Sessions
About us

The North Wind is an independent student publication serving the Northern Michigan University community. It is partially funded by the Student Activity Fee. The North Wind digital paper is published daily during the fall and winter semesters except on university holidays and during exam weeks. The North Wind Board of Directors is composed of representatives of the student body, faculty, administration and area media.

TIMES ARE CHANGING — FAFSA announced changes to its filing system in February.
Editorial — The "better" FAFSA
North Wind Editorial Board February 27, 2024

Pro athletes have rights too

Pro athletes have rights too

Sunday’s Detroit Lions game ended in heartbreak for fans of the pro-football team—a technical subtlety simultaneously revoked the literal-last second touchdown and ended the game. The cause of the controversial conclusion: contact between receiver Golden Tate’s knee and the turf before he reached the end zone.

Tate’s contact with the field wasn’t the only controversy surrounding players’ knees over the weekend, however. Before the Lions game, and games across the National Football League (NFL), players, coaches and team-owners knelt during the National Anthem in symbolic protest of remarks made by President Trump Friday night during a campaign trip to Alabama.

When Trump cycled through a tirade of fervent comments against NFL players who don’t stand during the playing or singing of “The Star Spangled Banner,” cheers of “USA, USA” rang out. When players knelt, raised their fists and linked arms in solidarity, waves of “boos” broke over stadium seats.

Since the nationally-televised protests, Trump has tweeted over 20 times in regard to the
objections; his argument: it’s disrespectful to ignore nationally-recognized procedures of patriotism. The argument of the nearly 200 players who protested: ignoring social justice and devaluing freedom of expression is offensive.

Story continues below advertisement

The avalanche of controversy has been triggered by both sides, but, no flag should be thrown for the players’ actions. Peaceful protest doesn’t mean you, “should be fired!”

Democracy exists to provide all perspectives with a voice; if citizens can express extremist views, then NFL players can take a knee. The difference between protests in Charlottesville and the NFL, however, is that the former was violent, whereas the latter was peaceful. Despite this, Trump labeled white nationalists as “very fine people” and named unified players as “son of a bitch[es].”

Trump claims his criticism has nothing to do with race, only respect for our country and our flag, and I believe him, but his comments Friday contradict a fundamental nucleus of democracy: the right of the people to peacefully protest. The President has a right to feature his individual perspective, but to uphold and propagate objective democracy requires poise, patience and parity.

Professional athletes may seem like superheroes, but they’re still human, and more importantly, citizens entitled to the rights of democracy. Censoring their solidarity and isolating them from the rest of the collective through a moral-argument by the figurehead of modern-democracy defies equality, and promotes privilege.

We should embrace the national influence of pro-athletes, so long as they appropriately
practice their rights. If we’re equal to them, then they inherently have the same right as we do. Issues of racial inequality would have persisted if it wasn’t for Jesse Owens and Tommie Smith advocating for change. So why should we bench players in the NFL?

Ultimately, patriotism is subjective; placing a hand over your heart may be your way of
expressing it, whereas kneeling during the National Anthem is the way of others. Both embody democracy, and both are equal in their shared rights. So, let’s transcend duality, and unite, because “E Pluribus Unum” means “out of many, one.”

More to Discover